Comparison of Grab Start between Elite and Trained Swimmers

Abstract

This study analysed motor control during front crawl swimming starts by elite and trained swimmers, based on comparisons of: 1) kinematic and kinetic parameters of the start and 2) variability of these parameters across 3 trials per swimmer. Given that the start time to the 15-m mark is greatly influenced by the swimming phase, the study also compared the stroking and coordinative parameters from water entry to 25-m in the 2 skill groups. The swimmers performed 3×25-m at the 50-m race-pace and used their preferential start technique (grab start). The elite swimmers showed better start organization as reflected by higher impulse values in the direction of intended displacement despite similar block phase durations. They then spent more time in the water entry, gliding and leg kicking phases, with shorter swimming phase duration and 15-m start time than the trained swimmers (p<0.05). The trained swimmers showed significantly lower values for stroke length and velocity (p<0.05) during the swimming phase. Analysis revealed low intra-subject variability (across the 3 trials) but high inter-subject variability, indicating that both elite and trained swimmers had mastered distinct, though different, motor patterns.

Key words

biomechanics - swimming - expertise - variability

References

• 1 Ashby BM, Heegaard JH. Role of arm motion in the standing long jump.  J Biomech. 2002;  35 1631-1637
• 2 Arellano R, Moreno FJ, Martinez M, Ona A. A Device for Quantitative Measurement of Starting Time in Swimming. In: Troup JP, Hollander AP, Strass D, Trappe SW, Cappaert JM, Trappe TA (eds) Swimming Science VII, London, E & FN SPON; 1996: 195-200
• 3 Barbosa TM, Bragada JA, Reis VM, Marinho DA, Carvalho C, Silva AJ. Energetics and biomechanics as determining factors of swimming performance: updating the state of the art.  J Sci Med Sports. 2010;  13 262-269
• 4 Bartlett R, Wheat J, Robins M. Is movement variability important for sports biomechanists?.  Sports Biomech. 2000;  6 224-243
• 5 Bartlett R. Movement coordination and movement variability.  Sports Biomech. 2007;  6 119-120
• 6 Benjanuvatra N, Lyttle A, Blanksby B, Larkin D. Force development profile of the lower limbs in the grab and track start, in swimming. Proceedings of XXII International symposium on Biomechanics in Sports ISBS. Faculty of Health Sciences University of Ottawa.  Ottawa. 2004;  399-402
• 7 Benjanuvatra N, Edmunds K, Blanksby B. Jumping ability and swimming grab-start performance in elite and recreational swimmers.  Int J Aquatic Res Educ. 2007;  1 231-241
• 8 Bland M, Altman D. Measurement error and correlation coefficients.  Br Med J. 1996;  313 41-42
• 9 Blanksby B, Nicholson L, Elliott B. Biomechanical analysis of the grab, track and handle starts: an intervention study.  Sports Biomech. 2002;  1 11-24
• 10 Blitvich J, McElroy G, Blanksby B, Clothier P, Pearson C. Dive depth and water depth in competitive swim starts.  J Swim Res. 2000;  14 33-39
• 11 Bloom J, Hosler W, Disch J. Differences in flight, reaction and movement times for the grab & conventional starts.  Swim Tech. 1978;  15 34-36
• 12 Breed RVP, Young WB. The effect of a resistance training program on the grab, track and swing starts in swimming.  J Sports Sci. 2003;  21 213-220
• 13 Chollet D, Chalies S, Chatard JC. A new index of coordination for the crawl: description and usefulness.  Int J Sports Med. 2000;  21 54-59
• 14 Cohen J. Statistical Power Analysis for the Behavioral Sciences. Hillsdale, NJ: Erlbaum; 1988
• 15 Cossor JM, Mason BR. Swim start performances at the Sydney 2000 Olympic Games. In: Blackwell JR, Sanders RH, (eds) XIX International Symposium on Biomechanics in Sports ISBS, San Francisco. 2001: 70-73
• 16 Davids K, Bennett S, Newell K. Movement system variability. Champaign, Illinois: Human Kinetics Publishers; 2006
• 17 Davids K, Glazier P, Araujo D, Bartlett R. Movement systems as dynamical systems, the functional role of variability and its implications for sports medicine.  Sports Med. 2003;  33 245-260
• 18 De la Fuente B, Garcia F, Arellano R. Are the Forces Applied in the Vertical Countermovement Jump Related to the Forces Applied During the Swimming Start. In: Chatard JC (ed) Swimming Science IX: University of Saint Etienne, Saint Etienne, France; 2003: 207-210
• 19 Disch JG, Hosler W, Bloom JJ. Effects of weight, height and reach on the performance of the conventional and grab starts in swimming. In: Terauds J, Bedingfield EW (eds) Swimming Science III. Baltimore: University Park Press; 1979: 215-221
• 20 Feltner ME, Fraschetti DJ, Crisp RJ. Upper extremity augmentation of lower extremity kinetics during countermovement vertical jumps.  J Sports Sci. 1999;  17 449-466
• 21 Fleiss J. The Design and Analysis of Clinical Experiments. New York: John Wiley and Sons; 1986
• 22 Harman EA, Rosenstein MT, Frykman PN, Rosenstein RM. The effects of arms and countermovement to vertical jumping.  Med Sci Sports Exerc. 1990;  22 825-833
• 23 Harriss DJ, Atkinson G. International Journal of Sports Medicine – Ethical Standards in Sport and Exercise Science Research.  Int J Sports Med. 2009;  30 701-702
• 24 Issurin V, Verbitsky O. Track Start versus Grab Start: evidence from the Sydney Olympic Games. In:, Chatard JC, (ed) Swimming Science IX, University of Saint Etienne, Saint Etienne, France. 2003: 213-217
• 25 Kollias I, Baltzopoulos V, Chatzinikolaou K, Tsirakos D, Vasiliadis I. Sex differences in kinematics and temporal parameters of the grab start. In: MacLaren D, Reilly T, Less A (eds) Biomechanics and Medicine in Swimming VI. 1992: 181-185
• 26 Krüger T, Wick D, Hohmann A, El-Bahrawi M, Koth A. Biomechanics of the Grab and Track Start Technique. In: Chatard JC, (ed). Swimming Science IX. University of Saint Etienne, Saint Etienne, France; 2003: 219-223
• 27 Mason B, Alcock A, Fowlie J. A Kinetic Analysis and Recommendations for Elite Swimmers Performing the Sprint Start. Proceedings of XXV ISBS Symposium Ouro Preto – Brazil; 2007: 192-195
• 28 McLean SP, Holthe MJ, Vint PF, Beckett KD, Hinrichs RN. Addition of an approach to swimming relay start.  J Appl Biomech. 2000;  16 342-355
• 29 Miller M, Allen D, Pein R. A kinetic and kinematic comparison of the grab and track starts in swimming. In: Chatard JC (ed). Swimming Science IX: University of Saint Etienne, Saint Etienne. France 2003: 231-235
• 30 Naemi R, Sanders RH. A “hydrodynamic” method of measuring the glide efficiency of a human swimmer.  J Biomech Eng. 2008;  130 061016
• 31 Newell KM. Constraints on the Development of Coordination. In: Wade MG, Whiting HTA (eds). Motor Development in Children: Aspects of Coordination and Control. Amsterdam: Martinus Nijhoff Publishers; 1986: 341-361
• 32 Pereira S, Ruschel C, Araùjo L. Biomechanical analysis of the underwater phase in swimming start.  Port J Sport Sci. 2006;  6 (S 02) 79-81
• 33 Ruschel C, Gassenferth Araujo L, Pereira S, Roesler H. Kinematical anlaysis of the swimming start: block, flight and underwater phases. Proceedings of XXV ISBS Symposium, Ouro Preto.  Brazil. 2007;  385-388
• 34 Sanders RH. Start technique – recent findings.  Available at: http://www.education.ed.ac.uk/cis/swim/papers4/rs5.html
• 35 Sanders RH, Byatt-Smith J. Improving Feedback on Swimming Turns and Starts Exponentially. Proceedings of XIX Symposium on Biomechanics in Sports, San Francisco; 2001: 91-94
• 36 Seifert L, Boulesteix L, Carter M, Chollet D. The spatial-temporal and coordinative structures in elite male 100-m front crawl swimmers.  Int J Sports Med. 2004;  25 1-8
• 37 Seifert L, Chollet D. Inter-Limb Coordination and Constraints in Swimming: A Review. Beaulieu NP (ed) Physical Activity and Children. Nova Science Publishers: New York; 2008: 65-69
• 38 Stevenson JR, Morehouse CA. Influence of starting-block angle on the grab start in competitive swimming. In: Terauds J, Bedingfield EW, (eds) Swimming Science III Baltimore: University Park Press. 1979: 207-214
• 39 Takeda T, Nomura T. What are the differences between grab and track start. In: Vilas-Boas JP, Alves F, Marques A, (eds) Swimming Science X Faculty of Sport, University of Porto, Porto, Portugal. 2006: 102-105
• 40 Thayer AL, Hay JG. Motivating start and turn improvement.  Swim Tech. 1984;  2 17-20
• 41 Trembley J, Fielder G. Starts, turns and finishes.  The Swim Coaching Bible. 2001;  189-206
• 42 Van Emmerik REA, Van Wegen EEH. On variability and stability in human movement.  J Appl Biomech. 2000;  16 394-406
• 43 Vantorre J, Seifert L, Fernandes RJ, Vilas Boas JP, Chollet D. Kinematical profiling of the front crawl start.  Int J Sport Med. 2010;  31 16-21
• 44 Vilas-Boas JP, Cruz MJ, Sousa F, Conceiçao F, Fernandes R, Carvalho J. Biomechanical Analysis of Ventral Swimming Starts: Comparison of the Grab Start with 2 Track Start Techniques. In: Chatard JC, (ed) Swimming Science IX, University of Saint Etienne, Saint Etienne, France; 2003: 249-253▪
• 45 Zatsiorsky VM, Bulgakova NZ, Chaplinsky NM. Biomechanical Analysis of Starting Techniques in Swimming. In: Terauds J, Bedingfield EW, (eds) Swimming Science III. Baltimore: University Park Press; 1979: 199-206

Correspondence